Battery Backup vs. Propane Generator — Which Home Power Solution is Right for You?

 By Alyshia and Jesse Camp, JCamp Electric 
Published in Northampton Living August 2025

When the power goes out, having a reliable backup system is crucial. Two popular options for homeowners are battery backup systems and propane generators. Each comes with its own set of benefits and trade-offs – understanding the differences can help you choose the best fit for your home.

BATTERY BACKUP SYSTEMS

Battery systems, like the Tesla Powerwall or Enphase, store electricity from the grid or solar panels and supply power during an outage.

Pros:
• Silent and Clean: They operate quietly and emit no fumes, especially when paired with solar.
• Low Maintenance: With no oil changes or moving parts, there's less upkeep.
• Fast Response: Power kicks in almost instantly during an outage.
• Smart Controls: Many systems offer app-based monitoring and control.

Cons:
• High Upfront Cost: Installation typically ranges from $20,000 to $30,000 or more.
• Limited Capacity: Most can only power essentials for 8 to 12 hours unless expanded.
• Lower Output: They may not support heavy appliances without multiple units.

Operating Costs:
Very low, especially with solar charging. Grid charging costs are minimal – often under $1 per day unless electricity rates are high.

PROPANE GENERATORS

Propane standby generators, such as those from Generac or Kohler, utilize stored propane to power your home in the event of a grid failure.

Pros:
• Reliable Long-Term Power: They can run for days or weeks with enough fuel.
• High Output: They easily support entire homes, including HVAC systems.
• Lower Initial Cost: Most systems cost between $10,000 and $15,000 to install (not including propane).
• Fuel Stability: Propane stores well and is widely available.

Cons:
• Noise and Emissions: They are louder than batteries and produce carbon dioxide.
• Regular Maintenance: They require oil changes, filters and testing.
• Fuel Storage Required: On-site propane tanks are necessary and occupy space.

Operating Costs:
Expect to spend $3 to $6 per hour, depending on load and propane cost. A full-day outage can cost $90 to $200 in fuel.

WHICH SHOULD YOU CHOOSE?

Battery backups are ideal for short outages, quiet operation and eco-conscious homeowners – especially those with solar energy systems. Propane generators are better for extended outages, whole-home coverage and lower upfront costs. If either of these options is installed with a smart, integrated panel, you can maximize the performance and longevity of your equipment.

Ultimately, your decision should reflect your power needs, budget and environmental priorities. Both systems offer peace of mind, just in different ways. JCamp Electric is here to talk through your decision and for all your energy-related needs. Visit us at jcampelectric.com.

Other Articles from this Issue…